From allegations of misconduct to an overturned conviction: The Muhammad case
A chronology of the investigation, prosecution and legal proceedings surrounding Abdul Malik Muhammad's murder conviction.
Abdul Malik Muhammad was 20 years old when he was taken into custody in connection with the 1999 fatal shooting of Damone Mims on Chicago's South Side. A few months after his 47th birthday, a Cook County judge overturned his murder conviction.
In the intervening years, Muhammad repeatedly sought to bring to the attention of state and federal courts what he contended were shortcomings in his defense, misconduct by police and irregularities in the investigation that led to his conviction.
It would take an independent investigation by the Illinois Torture Inquiry and Relief Commission to corroborate at least part of his account. And it would take another eight years for a judge to overturn his conviction.
Drawing on court records, the commission's investigative findings and other public records, Cook County Courtroom Observer has compiled a chronology of Muhammad's case, documenting the long road to an overturned conviction and his continuing fight for freedom.
This timeline will be updated as the case progresses.
May 1999: Damone Mims is fatally shot on Chicago's South Side.
April 2000: Chicago police bring Muhammad back from Seattle for questioning and conduct a series of lineups.
June 2000: Muhammad's attorney requests information about witnesses who failed to identify his client.
August 2000: Prosecutors represent that the results of identification procedures are contained in police reports provided to the defense.
November 2001: Muhammad is convicted of murder. He receives a 50-year prison sentence.
2004: The Illinois Appellate Court affirms his conviction.
2006: Muhammad files a post-conviction petition raising issues concerning unsuccessful police lineups. The petition is dismissed.
2010: A federal court denies Muhammad's petition for habeas corpus relief.
2014: Muhammad submits a claim to the Illinois Torture Inquiry and Relief Commission.
March 2018: Commission investigators independently confirm that at least one eyewitness failed to identify Muhammad in a lineup.
July 2018: The commission refers Muhammad's case to the Cook County Circuit Court for judicial review.
November 15, 2023: Muhammad earns a bachelor's degree from Northwestern University through its prison education program.
December 2023: The Illinois Appellate Court reverses a circuit court decision denying Muhammad an evidentiary hearing. The appellate court also orders the removal of the special prosecutor, finding an actual conflict of interest.
July 21–22, 2026: Judge Kantas hears evidence in Muhammad's case.
November 5, 2026: Kantas overturns Muhammad's murder conviction and orders a new trial.
November 18, 2026: Kantas denies Muhammad's request for pretrial release.
December 2, 2026: Muhammad's next scheduled court appearance.